News at Six Complaint Stage 1: BBC Response 4

Subject: BBC Complaints – Case number CAS-2854164-81M5MF
Date: Wed, 6 Aug 2014 17:19:37 +0100
From: <>

Dear Mr McNulty

We are sorry that you were not satisfied with our earlier response to your complaint and appreciate that you felt strongly enough to contact us again about the matter.

This is an automated email to confirm we received your complaint. Please do not reply to this email since it is generated from an unmonitored address. If you believe you have received this in error please contact us using our webform at and quoting any reference number we have provided.

In these circumstances we aim to investigate and reply to you normally within 20 working days (around four weeks) but we will contact you if we believe it may take longer. The time taken to reply at this stage depends on the detailed nature of the issues needing investigation, how many others need to be investigated and practical issues such as whether a production team is available or away on location.

In order to use the licence fee efficiently we may not investigate every issue if it does not suggest a substantive breach of guidelines, and may send the same reply to everyone if others have also complained about the same issues. This is in line with the full complaints procedure which you can read at:

We attach the text and reference number of your complaint below for your records:



Complaint Summary: Lack of due accuracy, impartiality & prominence

Full Complaint: Dear Lucia Fortucci, Thank you for your email of 06/08/2014. Video, audio or transcripts are no longer necessary as your email confirms the ONS statistics were given zero prominence or weight on the ‘News at Six’ on the day of their announcement (22 July 2014). I would argue that the ONS announcement is due greater prominence than the IMF’s for the following reasons: 1) The ONS statistic is a statement of hard scientific fact. The IMF’s forecast is an estimate, opinion, or guess. 2) The IMF’s forecast SUGGESTS the economy MAY BE moving marginal faster in an already predicted direction. The ONS statistic PROVES the deficit has moved significantly in the opposite direction to the one predicted. Therefore, the ONS statistic has much greater information, news and public interest value than the IMF forecast and is therefore due greater prominence, proving that the ‘News at Six’ on 22 July 2014 was in direct breach of Editorial Guidelines 3.4.21, 4.4.12, 4.4.13 and 14.4.4. I look forward to receiving the BBC’s opinion on why this is not the case. Please Note: I wish any discussion on this matter to be open and transparent to public scrutiny and therefore require all correspondence between the BBC and myself to be subject to that understanding.


Thank you again for contacting us.

BBC Complaints

NB This is sent from an outgoing account only which is not monitored. You cannot reply to this email address but if necessary please contact us via our webform quoting any case number we provided.


Chain of correspondence in this complaint:

Leave a Reply

Your e-mail address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.